Do You Matcha?
Matcha green tea is the highest grade and most potent green tea available. Its nutritional profile boasts high antioxidants, a strong amino acid content, and a good source vitamins and minerals. So, we wanted to know what makes this so-called “superfood” so special? Should we be drinking matcha everyday?
Green tea has been acclaimed as a healthy source of antioxidants for centuries. But, more recently, it’s health benefits have been overshadowed by its more popular sibling: matcha. And while matcha has always been a staple in Asian culture, the weight-loss movement in the United States made this product incredibly mainstream.
According to Mintel market research, green tea also has a reputation of being associated with weight loss. In response to this, matcha products have become increasingly popular in the United States.
In fact, this newly minted “mainstream” ingredient has claimed:
assist in the prevention of cancer
assist in the prevention of cardiovascular disease
However, while matcha, and green tea alike, certainly have a compliment of health benefits, there is a limited amount of research that proves these expansive claims.
“Human clinical evidence is still limited. Future research needs to define the actual magnitude of health benefits and establish the safe range of tea consumption.” (2010 Literature Review of Green Tea)
“Matcha is said to be the most powerful, mother of all, green teas.” (Mintel)
So before we lose ourselves to the matcha craze. The D2D team wanted to review this powerful ingredient and see what health benefits it could offer us…
Unlike traditional green tea, which is typically steeped in hot water and enjoyed, matcha is made from tencha green tea leaves and is ground into a powder, making matcha the more potent of the two. Thus rather than drinking just the steeped water, you are consuming the physical tea leaves.
A 2010 literature review of green tea research indicated that, “the health-promoting effects of green tea are mainly attributed to its polyphenol content [particularly flavanols and flavonols] which represent 30% of fresh leaf dry weight.” For matcha products, this antioxidant content is intensified because the leaves are consumed directly.
An ORAC test, or oxygen radical absorbance capacity, measures the antioxidant content of foods. According to the USDA, “early findings suggest that eating plenty of high-ORAC fruits and vegetables–such as spinach and blueberries–may help slow the processes associated with aging in both body and brain.”
Matcha is often served as a tea or latte, but the process is much more arduous than simply brewing a cup of tea. Additionally, cultivating matcha is bit different as well.
In order to properly cultivate the tea leaves, farmers cover the tencha plant and keep it in the shade for roughly four weeks before harvest. This process forces the plant to compensate for the lack of sunlight and in turn the plant produces a greater amount of an antioxidant called chlorophyll. This farming practice is what provides matcha tea with a dense of amino acid profile.
Plant-based catechins are antioxidants that are often found in tea as well as a diverse mix of foods like chocolate, berries, and fava beans. This shading process for growing matcha does reduce the amount of catechins found specifically in matcha— making traditional green tea a stronger source for this particular antioxidant.The decreased level of catechin’s in green tea is also said to decrease the traditionally bitter flavor of brewed green tea leaves.
Chlorophyll is often found in green plants. It is a a very powerful antioxidant that helps support detoxification, specifically aiding in the cleansing of your liver. A 2012 study performed at Oregon State University found that chlorophyll may also help protect your body against cancer. It is also believed to help support digestion and possess antiviral properties that can protect against bacteria entering your body.
One of the most prevailing amino acids that is present in matcha is L-theanine. New research on this amino acid indicates that it can help to control stress. In fact, Buddhist monks are known to have consumed matcha tea before meditating to help concentration. This amino acid helps regulate the digestion of caffeine present in matcha. Rather than a quick burst of energy, L-theanine slows the rate of absorption. According to Mintel market research, “the elevated levels of theanine in matcha help control the caffeine ‘hit’ and provide a more sustained energy boost for a longer period of time.” (Mintel). Additionally, and perhaps most importantly, a 2009 study indicated that L-theanine may “help in the prevention and treatment of Alzheimer’s disease.”
Nutrient profile of matcha powder from Matcha Source
The process of harvesting and creating matcha makes the final product much stronger than traditional tea blends. The elevated caffeine levels and powerful vitamin, mineral, and antioxidant component has made this “ingredient” into a very popular product.
The food and drink industry has responded to the many recognized health benefits of matcha tea. According to Mintel market research, “the number of global food and drink launches containing matcha has more than doubled between 2012 and 2014.” And it continues to climb— making matcha more and more mainstream. In the U.S., matcha lattes are available at almost every coffee and tea chain, including Starbucks and Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf. In Asia, you can even find matcha in Kit-Kat and Crunch bars! But be wary, while these candy bars and latte’s may be tasty, they are often packed with sugar and do not provide the same health benefits as a pure matcha powder.
And while tea is certainly good for you, there are two things to be aware of with regards to matcha products:
False marketing claims
A single serving (8oz) of matcha tea as roughly 70mg of caffeine, whereas the average green tea has roughly 25mg per 8oz serving. Black tea has more caffiene than green tea with roughly 45mg per serving. However, this is not to say the caffeine levels in matcha are too high— an 8oz Starbucks (“tall”) contains roughly 165 mg of caffeine. Thus, the increased caffeine is not a problem if you are supplementing your coffee for a matcha beverage.
3 cups of green tea = 2 cups of black tea =
1 matcha latte = 1/2 cup of coffee
But if you are adding the additional caffeine into your routine, could you be negatively affecting your health?
It is important to note that (as with all foods) the negative affects of overconsumption does exist— even with green tea. In a 2005 study on hamsters, researchers found that a high consumption of green tea can negatively affected the animal’s liver.
According to the 2005 literature review, “green tea should not be taken by patients suffering from heart conditions or major cardiovascular problems.” Additionally, the U.S. Dietary Guidelines recommends no more than 300-400 milligrams of caffeine per day. This is the absolute maximum that should be consumed throughout the day. Keep in mind, caffeine is a drug and its intake should be carefully monitored. Meaning, if you are already a coffee drinker, you might want to use discretion when adding matcha to your diet.
Essentially, you have to be a mindful consumer. Every diet is individualistic, and while matcha is a good source of antioxidants, amino acids, vitamins and minerals, if you are sensitive to caffeine or you suffer from a heart condition, consume matcha with caution.
As matcha becomes more mainstream, food processing companies will use its understood health value to sell products that might not be as healthy as you may think. For example, the average matcha latte has anywhere from 18-26 grams of sugar. As matcha’s health benefits become yet another marketing claim, it is important to make sure you are putting the cleanest form of this product into your body.
To that end, some recent studies found that metals, such as aluminum and lead, as well as pesticides can be found in tea. The literature review of green tea also noted the “presence of aluminum” as one of the harmful effects of tea overconsumption. Moreover, if there are contaminants in the soil, they can be present on the tea leaves as well. This is particularly concerning with matcha as you are consuming the leaf itself. With green tea, for example, steeping the leaves helps filter the metal from the leaf. If there is pesticide residue on the leaf, your body is directly ingesting it. So, when buying your matcha, make sure you are confident in the farming practices of the supplier.
“The green tea plant is known to absorb lead at a higher rate than other plants from the environment, and lead also can build up on the surface of the leaves. The majority of the lead is staying with the leaf. If you’re brewing it with a tea bag, the tea bag is very effectively filtering out most of the lead by keeping those tea leaves inside the bag. So it’s fine as long as you’re not eating the leaves.” —Dr. Tod Cooperman, Consumer Lab
The Bottom Line:
Matcha can be a very healthy way to get good vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants as well as a boost of caffeine. However, there is limited (human) research to support the long-term health claims that are made for this beverage. If you plan to incorporate matcha into your diet, great! But if you are already a strong caffeine consumer, you might want to proceed with caution.
Bjarnadottir, Adda, MS. “Matcha – Even More Powerful Than Regular Green Tea?” Authority Nutrition. N.p., 18 Aug. 2016. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.
Chacko, Sabu M., Priya T. Thambi, Ramadasan Kuttan, and Ikuo Nishigaki. “Beneficial effects of green tea: A literature review.” US National Library of Medicine. National Center for Biotechnology Information, 06 Apr. 2010. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.
Dulloo , AG, C. Duret, and D. Rohrer. “Efficacy of a green tea extract rich in catechin polyphenols and caffeine in increasing 24-h energy expenditure and fat oxidation in humans.” U.S. National Library of Medicine. National Center for Biotechnology Information, 07 Dec. 1999. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.
Group, Edward, DC. “10 Amazing Benefits of Chlorophyll.” Dr. Group’s Natural Health & Organic Living Blog. Global Healing Center, 06 Jan. 2014. Web. 11 Jan. 2017.
Jones, Laura. “Matcha: The Mother of All Tea’s.” Mintel Food & Drink. Mintel, Aug. 2013. Web.
Kim, TI, YK Lee, SG Park, IS Choi, HK Park, JO Ban, and Et. Al. “L-Theanine, an amino acid in green tea, attenuates beta-amyloid-induced cognitive dysfunction and neurotoxicity: reduction in oxidative damage and inactivation of ERK/p38 kinase and NF-kappaB pathways.” U.S. National Library of Medicine. National Center for Biotechnology Information, 1 Dec. 2009. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.
McBride, Judy. “High-ORAC Foods May Slow Aging.” USDA Agricultural Research Service. United States Department of Agriculture, 08 Feb. 1999. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.
Minotto, Jodie. “Tea, Malt and Other Hot Drinks.” Mintel Food & Drink. Mintel, Mar. 2015. Web.
Minotto, Jodie. “Consumer August 2016: Tea, Malts, and Other Hot Drinks.” Mintel Food & Drink. Mintel, Aug. 2016. Web.
O’connor, Anahad. “What’s in Your Green Tea?” The New York Times. The New York Times, 22 May 2013. Web. 11 Jan. 2017.
“Tencha – Pure Elegant Flavor .” JAPANESE GREEN TEA | HIBIKI-AN. Hibiki-An, n.d. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. <http://www.hibiki-an.com/contents.php/cnID/53>.
“The Benefits of Tea.” University of California, Berkeley Wellness. Remedy Health Media, LLC , 01 Apr. 2010. Web. 09 Jan. 2017.